How to Write an Argument Analysis Essay

Table of contents

The task

To write a good argument analysis essay you have to juggle a lot at once: explicit and implicit contentions, arguments, audiences, persuasive techniques and visual analysis. Unfortunately, many students get confused and overwhelmed, only to fall into the trap of summarising the articles rather than engaging with the real aim of the task.

That aim is to analyse how an author tries to convince an audience to adopt a point of view, through a range of written and visual persuasive techniques. That's always easier said than done, but if you find Argument Analysis daunting, you're in the right place. Let's break down the steps to a truly effective response.

Annotating and planning

When you annotate, focus on two things: blocking out the piece's arguments in the order they appear, and identifying the persuasive techniques you'll discuss.

Your essay structure should mirror that chronological blocking. It might look something like this:

  1. Opening / Argument 1
  2. Argument 2
  3. Argument 3 / Call to action

There may well be more than three arguments, though. Always shape your structure (that is, the number of body paragraphs) to fit the structure of the piece, not the other way around.

As you annotate, watch for shifts in how the argument develops, because your essay should track those changes too. Ask yourself:

  • How does the author address different audiences?
  • Where do they change tone and why?
  • Do they base later arguments on different kinds of appeals and strategies?

Introductions

Your introduction only needs to do two things: contextualise the piece, and show that you understand its contention and purpose. It should be simple and straightforward, since the large majority of your marks come from your paragraphs.

Here's a simple but highly effective template you can memorise, adapt and use:

Recently, the issue of [NAME ISSUE] has emerged in [FURTHER DETAILS]. In their [FORM] in [SOURCE], [AUTHOR'S FULL NAME] [TONE ADVERB] contends that [CONTENTION]. [AUTHOR'S LAST NAME] seeks to sway [AUDIENCE/S] to [PURPOSE].

That's it, nothing crazy! Save your firepower for the body paragraphs.

Body paragraphs: structure and analysis

Topic sentences

Your topic sentence should introduce the argument you're analysing. At a higher level, it should also signpost how the argument is developing, for example how it builds on the one before. Here are some templates you can use:

  • "Beginning with / Shifting to a more [cynical, optimistic, pragmatic, etc.] argument / approach, the author posits that / entreats [audiences] to…"
  • "Transitioning / Modulating to a [different tone / argument type], the author argues that…"
  • "Inaugurating their piece with an appeal to…, the author immediately establishes [credibility / stakeholdership / rapport with the audience], priming readers towards [point of view]."
  • "Having established.... the author moves to..."
  • "Finalising the piece, the author returns to..."

Aim to include a tone word in every topic sentence. The easiest way is to put a tone adverb before your verb: "The author cynically argues that…" or "The author sympathetically acknowledges…"

Analysis: the What / How / Why method

This is the absolute crux of your essay! Effective analysis answers three questions about the evidence:

Step
The question
Example
What
What is the evidence and/or persuasive technique being used?
An appeal to tradition; a juxtaposition of word choices
How
How does it position the audience to think, feel, do or desire? Be as specific as possible.
Local nature lovers are positioned to feel dread and horror towards the potential destruction of the community's beloved wetlands.

Employees are spurred to see the new company policy as an exciting and nourishing initiative that will not only improve profit margins, but also workers' wellbeing.
Why
Why does the author want to position the audience this way? What's their ultimate goal?
In doing so, the author calls on locals to reject the proposed development plans.

Thus, the author assuages potential concerns about the new policy, framing it as a decision driven by inclusivity and altruism.

The "why" is where you link your analysis back to the overarching argument or contention. We recommend doing this only a couple of times per paragraph, to avoid needless repetition.

Zooming out vs zooming in

A strong essay balances two kinds of analysis: zooming in on microscopic language choices, and zooming out to look at broad techniques and the text's structure. Our guide to Persuasive Techniques for VCE English walks through a range of big-picture and small-picture techniques, with plenty of examples.

In the example below, the student starts by analysing a broad appeal, then zooms in to unpack the author's juxtaposition of specific words and their connotations.

O'Brien appeals to tradition in her assertion that the "existing Yarra building" should be "retained" given it is part of the "original design for the square" and is used for "markets, public events and conventions". In doing so, readers actively involved in the social or cultural life of Melbourne, or perhaps even those who passingly visit the Square as part of their daily commute, are positioned to view the proposed build as an unsolicited encroachment on the traditions of the lives of ordinary Melburnians, given the cultural significance Federation Square has as a symbol of Melbourne and even Australia. Juxtaposing the "thousands" who "flock" to the Square to "watch sporting events, hold protests, watch fireworks, film screenings and attend festivals and markets" with the "oppressive presence hulking over" the area serves then to further generate anger and resentment towards Apple for destroying the cultural activities of Melburnians. Given the connotations of community spirit and participation associated with the extensive list of activities that the space facilitates, diametrically opposed to the images of a gargantuan, imposing construction, readers are poised to completely reject such an inequitable proposal […]

Visual analysis

Visual analysis is often neglected, but done well it can significantly lift your marks. There are three steps:

  1. What does the image show, and what claim or argument does it support? "The accompanying cartoon depicting young children as astronauts reading books serves to amplify the author's claim that the new book program will enrich young learners' minds."
  2. What specific visual techniques are used? "Specifically, the space setting and astronaut suits serve as visual symbols of…"
  3. How does it affect the audience? "…eliciting a sense of excitement and awe from parents looking to support their children's academic development."

We also recommend pairing visual elements with specific quotes from the text, so you can analyse how written and visual language work together to persuade.

Here's an example of strong visual analysis. It's precise, and it's woven into the discussion of the argument and the written techniques rather than tacked on at the end:

The inclusion of a photograph depicting the "proposed flagship design" of the Apple store serves to bolster O'Brien's portrayal of the building as an unnecessary obstruction in the cultural hub of Melbourne. With the instantly recognizable irregular geometric patterns of Federation Square surrounding the new "flagship" building, readers are reminded of the disruption that this building will create to their daily lives, having been accustomed to an open, public area rather than the more constricted and uninviting image the design suggests.

The importance of the audience

To score well, you need to avoid mindlessly repeating the word "audience" and start considering how the author addresses a wide variety of stakeholders in different ways. As practice, try writing a whole essay without using the word "audience" once!

Examiners reward a relentless, specific focus on audience impact, so make your analysis precise rather than vague. Audiences can be grouped by demographics (who they are) and by values (what they care about). Here are some examples, though there are countless more depending on the piece and its context:

Category
Examples
Demographics
Older / younger; families, parents and children; working class, blue collar, white collar, upper class and wealthy; religious / atheist; married / unmarried; locals, tourists and foreigners; urban, suburban and regional; students; professionals; executives and managers; politicians and bureaucrats; homeowners; specific ethnic groups
Values
Patriotic or nationalistic; conservative / progressive (or traditionalist / progressivist); environmentally conscious; egalitarian or socially conscious; fiscally conscious; animal lovers; family-oriented; pragmatist; scrutinist, sceptic or rationalist; health-conscious; technophiles, pro-tech, anti-tech and luddites; adventurous; cautious

The strongest analysis often combines the two: not just "locals", but "locals with a strong sense of civic pride".

Here's an example of analysis with a strong, insightful focus on audience:

Painting a highly negative portrayal of Apple Inc. through descriptors such as "tax-dodging multinational" and "erosion of public space to private corporations", O'Brien seeks to capitalize on her local readership's loyalty and patriotism towards the City of Melbourne to implicitly suggest that the building will endanger all that they hold dear, with the "well-used public building" replaced by "oppressive" international forces. Given the stark contrast between the comfort and sense of community in the "public amenity" and the sterility and coldness of the "private corporations", readers strongly affiliated with the Square and all it represents are encouraged to view Apple Inc. as an almost evil corporation far removed from the cultural identity of Melbourne.

Vocabulary and verbs

A wide vocabulary keeps your analysis precise and formal, and helps you avoid long, vague sentences. Below are some useful verbs, split into two groups: verbs for how the author presents their arguments, and verbs for how the author positions their audience.

Type
Verbs
Argument verbs (what the author does)
Contends, posits, advances, asserts, frames, constructs, portrays, appeals to, concedes, rebuts
Audience verbs (what the author does to readers)
Positions, enjoins, compels, urges, implores, manoeuvres, evokes / elicits (feelings), spurs, bids, orients

Important note: these words are not interchangeable. Each has its own specific meaning, and that's exactly what makes them precise. There are also plenty more you can add, but this list is a strong foundation. Alongside it, we recommend building a bank of adjectives and adverbs for describing tone (lest we see another essay with the words "passionate tone"...).

Common mistakes

  1. Evaluating rather than analysing: Never judge the quality of the author's argument. Avoid phrases like "The author effectively persuades…" or "The author deceivingly / wrongly states that…"
  2. Implying the techniques work: Similarly, never suggest the audience is definitely persuaded. Phrases like "the author makes the audience…" or "the audience is persuaded to think that…" overstate the case. Stay objective with low-modality language, such as "the audience is positioned to…" or "the author urges readers to recognise…"
  3. Summarising rather than analysing: Your focus should always be on how the author uses techniques to persuade, not on retelling what the text says. We've all read the text, we don't need a summary!
  4. Using overly long quotes: Short, embedded quotes are the most effective. This isn't Text Response, so you don't need to show off your memorisation. Long quotes also usually mean you aren't zooming in closely enough on specific word choices.
  5. Being too generic about the effect: Be specific about the feelings, thoughts, values and desires the author appeals to. Instead of "the author positions the audience to feel afraid", try "the author positions readers to fear the consequences of X, as it is implied they will threaten Y."
  6. Repeating the same points: High-scorers usually make this mistake because they are perfectionists. Be selective about the evidence you discuss. VCAA doesn't expect you to identify every technique; your essay would be ten pages long if you did. An obsessive focus on detail also leads to repetition, since different techniques often do the same job. Instead, choose evidence that lets you explore a broad range of ideas.

Further resources

If you need more support with Argument Analysis, check out our related guides:

But to put it all simply (perhaps too simply), the best way to approach an argument analysis essay is to keep asking how: how the author builds and shifts their argument, and how each technique positions specific readers to think, feel or act. Keep that question at the centre of every paragraph!